The Ten Commandments: Two Biblical Versions

 

Two Versions: Exodus 20:1-17 and Deuteronomy 5:6-21

    The "Ten Commandments" or "Decalogue" (from the Greek, "Ten Words") "were designed to convey to the Israelites a representative sampling of the laws to be given subsequently but was in no sense to be a summary of them, much less an act of legislation in their own right. Thus it [the Decalogue] contains some of each of the two main types of religious law: those pertaining to the individual's obligations toward God and those pertaining to his relations with other people. It also contains both forms of command, positive and prohibitive. ... The Bible nowhere refers to the Decalogue as ten commandments. The text of the Decalogue does not even divide naturally into pronouncements; the number of commands (positive and negative) is more than ten, whereas the number of topics is nine. ... Yet the Bible refers to it as 'the ten words'...apparently using this round number as an expression of totality, as is found in other places in biblical and Talmudic literature. Various methods arose for dividing the passage into ten commandments. ... The two versions of the Decalogue (in Ex.and Dt.) differ in several particulars, all of which are stylistic and not substantive in nature." [from The Oxford Dictionary of the Jewish Religion (1997), pp.683f.] There are differences among Christians in the numbering of the Commandments.