Saint Andrew's Episcopal Church
Lake Worth, Florida

A Celebration of the Feast of All Saints [Nov. 6, 2004]

Canon Richard T. Nolan

        In our home we have pictures and items that warmly remind us of some of the people, places, and events dear to us. To be sure, we could get along without such reminders, but they do enrich our lives. However, it would be a bit peculiar, if we spent an inordinate time gazing at any of them, or chatting with photographs of beloved people whether alive or dead. An obsession with pictures or items is at best unhealthy and at worst delusional. Moreover, too many of them would become clutter.

        Last Monday was the annual Feast of All Saints, and today, the first Sunday following, the Church’s calendar encourages its Sunday observance, too. Originally All Saints’ Day was set aside to honor all martyrs, and it soon evolved as a commemoration of all the departed, canonized Saints. At the time of the Reformation, the New Testament understanding of "saint" as including all believers living and dead was recovered, and among some Churches the feast be¬came a celebration of the unbro¬ken unity of the whole church – the “Communion of Saints.” (Some observances, however, focus only on the departed.) Needless to say, at no time were saints, however defined, regarded as perfect Christians, but as individuals on a pilgrimage toward the full life in Christ represented by the spirit of the Beatitudes read in tonight’s Gospel. Like pictures and items around a home, a Saint’s life might serve as a reminder, especially as an inspiring example of a particular style of Christian commitment.

        Unfortunately, the whole custom has developed into a complex, often superstitious, Disney-like enterprise. The most familiar is the named Saints canonized by the Roman Catholic Church and followed by many other Christians as well. There are now at least 20,000 such Saints. From a 21st century viewpoint, many of them appear to have been quite mentally ill. Roman Catholic theologian Richard McBrien has noted that many, perhaps most, never entered a committed loving relationship with another human being, raised a family, or held an ordinary job. The current pope has canonized or placed in the canonization process nearly 500 new Saints, usually contemporary martyrs, clergy, monks and nuns - at least a couple of whom may have never actually existed according to Roman Catholic historians. The majority of these Saints are so removed from our lives that, for the most part, we would not value them as realistic models for our lives; indeed, they are irrelevant. (By the way, The Episcopal Church has no canonization process as such, though, through a process of our triennial General Convention, we do add to our calendar the names of departed, exemplary men and women without any “Saint” prefix.)

        A good number of Christians go far beyond the inspirational function of canonized Saints by praying to them and asking favors of them, such that their obsession yields a whole range of junior gods. And, then there is the matter of certain relics: supposed pieces of Saints’ corpses to be venerated, a damnable practice unworthy of even a Disney classification.

        In the Massachusetts Episcopal church where I was baptized and active for all my pre-college years, we observed none of the individual Saint’s days, though we did celebrate the annual All Saints’ Day. Our rector was suspicious of what could easily become gadgets, superstitions, and clutter interfering with, even becoming substitutes for, the worship of God alone. A significant number of people involved in all religious bodies seem eager to elaborate, complicate, and even distort, their relationships with God and their faith community by add-ons. When such trappings truly enhance their basic religious commitments, they can be awe-inspiring! However, when any of them becomes a focus, it becomes an idol, a false mini-god.

        Like my first rector, I am very reluctant to make church life (especially worship) fussy, complicated, or mere entertainment. During my 41 ordained years, I have participated in some Services with so much extra “stuff” that the liturgical ministers were not worshipping; they were just performing. I am so aware of humanly designed hazards to keeping the related Commandments recorded in our Prayer Book (pp. 317f.) “God spake these words, and said: I am the Lord thy God who brought thee out of the land of Egypt, out of the house of bondage. Thou shalt have none other gods but me. Thou shalt not make to thyself any graven image, nor the likeness of any thing that is in heaven above, or in the earth beneath, or in the water under the earth; thou shalt not bow down to them, nor worship them.” It seems to me that our love for God involves the prudent keeping of these perceptive Commandments. Because you and I desire to worship God with due reverence, we need to be on guard against the twisting of any religious practices or items into more than wholesome reminders which rightly evoke the real presence of the Godly in our midst and within our lives.

        For me, the commemoration of All Saints is a time when I am reminded of fallible, faithful fellow Christians, living and dead - a few known to me, most unknown. It is an acknowledgement of my fellowship with all faithful Christians past and present, both the famous and those known to God alone. A pause to remember them, and myself, as the “Communion of Saints” warms my heart, opens my mind, strengthens my will, and enriches my life.