THE EPISCOPAL CHURCH OF
BETHESDA-BY-THE-SEA,
PALM BEACH, FLORIDA

Pentecost XXI - Proper 23B [October 12, 1997]
Canon Richard T. Nolan

So here I am in the pulpit of the Episcopal Church in Palm Beach, a town not known for being impoverished, with the task of preaching on a Gospel text that says "go, sell what you own, and give the money to the poor ... How hard it will be for those who have wealth to enter the Kingdom of God." Further complicating my task is the strong feeling in most congregations that certain topics - like money - are distasteful and unsuitable for sermons. How splendid to be in this spot this morning!

Do you think that Jesus would have said such things to the rich young man, if it were known that he faced massive medical expenses for his spouse, parents or children? Or if he happened to be a generous benefactor of many worthy religious and charitable organizations? Is a vow of poverty prerequisite to being a disciple of Christ? Are all well-to-do people despicable?

In the Bible approval of wealth is found in stories about the Genesis patriarchs and elsewhere. That riches are a gift and a blessing is part of the tradition. While hard work and resolution are commended, acquisitiveness, covetousness, love of money, and social injustices are emphatically condemned. Biblical writers knew that these vices are likely to foster insensitivity to godly values and promote callousness about harm done to others. In the Bible, wealth is given by God for the purposes of meeting the needs of the poor. Provision for them is a major purpose of work, not the accumulation of wealth sought for its own sake. It is clear that the rich are to be stewards of their resources, which ultimately belong to God.

In Jesus' day the moneyed minority were the possessors of abundant land, gold, silver and natural resources taken from oppressed and exploited, ordinary people. The treasures of the rich, including their surplus fortunes, were hoarded; their abundance was not shared - not shared even through reinvestments in profitable activities that could ultimately benefit the needy through their own labor. Moreover, the rich tended to view their resources as an approving gift from God - with not a little contempt for the poor. Additionally, some idolized their wealth; they had been willingly seduced to worship only what they could see and quantify. They defined their most fundamental identity, who they truly are, in terms of their possessions. No wonder we hear elsewhere in Scripture the words of Mary's song: "He has filled the hungry with good things, and the rich he has sent empty away." (Luke 1:53)

We might also ask, "Who are the poor?" Is their poverty self-inflicted, the consequences of laziness and financial incompetence? In the Bible the primary view is that their situation is not a consequence of personal failings, but a result of social factors, particularly injustices visited upon them by the wealthy. In that setting a poor person or family had no hope whatsoever of improving their economic condition. They are needy, without power, and abused by those with greater power. They do not have the capacity to provide the essentials of life for themselves. In those days the vast majority of people were the "poor," not just a minority, and not to be confused with the indolent of any age.

It is within this context that on his way to Jerusalem Jesus met the rich young man, who asked "Good Teacher, what must I do to inherit eternal life?" After challenging him to think about what he was saying, Jesus probed further. We gather from the text that the young man's obedience to traditional Commandments was insufficient, and his attachment to his wealth was an impediment to genuine discipleship. Notice that Jesus did "love him" and never condemned his wealth, which was morally neutral. His assets were not sinful, but they were problematic. He was not a bad man, just short-sighted, a bit pitiful. In the eyes of the Lord, his passive respectability and security were insufficient. Sadly, he was unable to contemplate a life without the stuff with which he had been sustained. Just perhaps, with earthly treasure in hand, the young man wanted to make sure he had bought into the treasure of the Kingdom of God as well. When he realized he couldn't have it all on his terms, this fellow "was shocked and went away grieving." The Gospel is harsh with the self-serving rich of Jesus' day, because they could have so much more if they were better stewards of what they had. Jesus shattered the notion that the wealthy elite were automatically closer to God.

Some Christians believe wholeheartedly that all of the various sayings of Jesus are absolute laws to be implemented immediately, in this case to "sell what you own, and give the money to the poor." However, to perceive his words as formal rules for policy-making is to miss the point. Instead, everything he teaches in the realm of human affairs is designed to integrate outward behavior with inner disposition. From him we learn that it is not sufficient just to conform outwardly to Commandments. Merely "going by the book" is falling short. Rather, good actions must be bound up with appropriate motives, intentions, and sentiments that claim individuals in all their relationships. In this sense, Jesus' teachings are radical; they get to the root of the matter - a real orientation of the whole person toward God and a life of active righteousness. By implication, Our Lord's directives invoke the necessity of God's grace for any of us to walk his demanding path.

Christ's many, severe teachings have an additional function. They are designed to illustrate what life would be like for an individual totally dedicated to God. They interpret the perfected life in covenant with God; they portray Jesus' own life: a life of generosity without so much as an inclination toward selfishness, malevolence, betrayal, deception, or other flaws. In addition, the demands of the Gospel symbolize the fully established Kingdom of God, the Kingdom consisting of truly faithful persons living in a transfigured community of mature love, a community of justice without an exploited, hopeless poor! Christ taught that both in the present and in the future, earthly measures of power and status do not apply in the kingdom of God. His teachings expose our often foolish ways and are beacons for our journey, drawing us ever closer to God's Word.

Jesus is not a philosopher designing a tight ethical system of rules and regulations applicable to everyone everywhere under all prevailing societal conditions. Nonetheless, he provides us with a context for discerning moral options, his (neither soft nor easy) "Summary of the Law" - "Thou shalt love the Lord thy God with all thy heart, and with all thy soul, and with all thy mind. This is the first and great Commandment. And the second is like unto it: Thou shalt love thy neighbor as thyself." In Jesus' own words "On these two commandments hang all the Law and the Prophets." The Summary is the only absolute Commandment upon which all else depends during our journey toward the fullness and perfection of the Kingdom. His many biddings flow from the Summary to particular circumstances, including the right use of our financial resources for true social victims. From him we learn that each of us is under an obligation to promote the interests of others with whom we come in contact, whether at home or at work. Mutual love, justice, unselfishness, humility, equal regard, and generosity of spirit, all accompanied by God's Grace, are emphasized in all human associations. One might say that the Christian life is the loving concern for the well-being of persons under the inspiration of and devotion to Jesus and the ideals he personifies, with special concern for the poor.

In his demanding Summary of the Law Christ has provided each of us with the moral context for our lives. We are challenged in today's Gospel Reading to face the difficulty of entering the Kingdom of God when impermanent material things have a firm hold on us. You and I are challenged to reflect on whether we possess our material resources or whether they possess us, whether we identify ourselves primarily as children of God and inheritors of everlasting life or as addicts to stuff that will pass away. We are confronted with the Gospel's requirement for economic justice and its implications for those among us who are policy-makers powerful in business, industry, and government. We are faced with the problem of wealth both for those who have wealth and for those who yearn for it.

Later in this Service, when we present our offerings at God's altar, we affirm the Creator as the source and owner of all we have. We acknowledge our gratitude and our stewardship: the wisdom to use our resources responsibly and not only for ourselves. In this regard, there is no precise formula for Christian stewardship; each of us must examine our own circumstances and consciences. Furthermore, rich or not, every one of us is challenged by the Gospel of Christ to examine any and all barriers to a full life that may exist for us individually and corporately. Jesus invites us to give up all the impediments in our lives so that we may have that everlasting life which can begin here and now. Moreover, we should not become overconfident that we have ever reached the last word on such affairs. I suspect that in all matters Jesus would offer harder sayings that would jolt us, humble us, guide us, and grace us to keep the pilgrimage advancing, during this, our journey toward the Kingdom of God. Amen.


Resources:

Consultations with Jeffrey S. Beebe
Burrows, Ch. 17 "Moral and Social Ideals" in An Outline of Biblical

Theology (1946)

Coogan, "Poor" in The Oxford Companion to the Bible (1993)
Gomes, Ch. 14 "The Bible and Wealth" in The Good Book (1996)
Mealand, "Wealth" in The Westminster Dictionary of Christian Ethics (1986)
Mott, "Wealth" and "Poor" in The HarperCollins Bible Dictionary (1996)
"Mark 10:23-31, Wealth and Discipleship" in The New Interpreter's Bible (1996)
"Mark 10:17-31, The Rich Young Man and Teaching On Wealth" in Harper's Bible Commentary (1988)